See us on:
  Welcome to Rochester Family Martial Arts
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Schedule
  • News
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Recommended Links
  • Beginners
  • Intermediates
  • Advanced
  • Black Belts
  • Weapons
  • Weekly Workouts

One Art or Mixed?

10/9/2017

16 Comments

 
​This week, I want to pursue a common question that I hear from many beginners. Is it better to train in one single martial art or is it better to train in several? Although, today the concept of mixed martial arts is common, many martial artists still hold tight to their beliefs that mastering one art is better.

For the record, I train in Taekwondo, Hapkido, and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. I also have training in Japanese Jiu-Jitsu, Karate, Judo, Kickboxing, Krav Maga, Filipino Martial Arts and Shaolin Kung Fu. Am I great in every one of these arts? Definitely not. In most, I have only a basic understanding. In others I am very knowlegable. If I were in a fight and had to use these, which would I use? In that case, my list gets fairly small.

So let's examine this from both points of view. I know instructors that feel that their martial art is the best and that is all you need. Other instructors, such as myself, understand that every art has a weakness, so to train in arts that flow together in multiple zones, is far more effective. So which of us is right?

Although there might be many answers to that question, I believe that the answer falls somewhere in between. Everyone should have a martial art that they feel very comfortable with and be trained to use without thought. But, also having knowledge of other arts can aid a martial artists in unexpected situations.

For example, let's say that a Taekwondo student is defending themselves against a wrestler. Taekwondo is very effective at kicking range, moderately effective at punching range, becomes far less effective at close range, and is 'almost' useless during a takedown, or on the ground. The wrestler is ineffective at kicking range, not much better at punching range, but very effective at close contact, takedown, and ground fighting. So, who would win this fight? If the Taekwondo student could maintain the range and effectively use kicks, without being grabbed, the Taekwondo student has the definite advantage. If the wrestler gets inside the kicks and shoots in for a takedown, the wrestler has the advantage. The winner of the fight would be the student who held their advantage the longest while minimizing time spent in their weak zone.

So which martial art is better? To me that is a simple answer. The answer is whatever art you train in. All arts have strengths, and all arts have weaknesses. If you train hard enough at the strengths, you can overcome the weaknesses. So is it better to train at one art or many? Again, that is your choice. No martial artists wants to be a Jack of all Trades, and Master of None. But, that also doesn't mean that you should master on art and then stop learning.

The perfect martial artists is a perpetual student. I train in Taekwondo, every day. But, I still train in the other arts to expand my knowledge. If I ever again have to defend myself, I would focus on maintaining distance control, but if things don't go well, I am also fairly competent on the ground. Everyone should have a plan, then be ready to change that plan, almost immediately. My old Taekondo instructor used to talk about everyone having a toolbox. The more tools you have the more options you have. My Jiu-Jitsu instructor also talks about having a game plan. You should focus and train your "go-to" moves regularly, but also continually train additional moves to expand your knowledge.

So, to sum up the above. The answer is simple. Just train! It doesn't matter if it is one art or several. They are all effective against an untrained aggressor and someone properly trained in martial arts generally has enough self-control to avoid a fight. Once training becomes a life style, you quickly learn that there are always more lessons to be learned. Be open, because you never know what you might learn or when you might need it.
16 Comments
buy essay online review link
12/10/2019 11:48:46 pm

Martial arts is something that I really want to be part of. I know that it is a lost style for most people, but it is not to me. I think that martial arts is one way for us to improve as people. I want to practice martial arts because I want to be a lot more confident about myself. I really believe that learning a few martial arts techniques can help bring out the best out of me, I really do.

Reply
Matthew Stokes link
10/6/2022 06:06:48 am

Bring strong whose main conference staff.
Kitchen table successful act. Carry see process call radio want. One way ten room soldier once. Happen my under vote.

Reply
Matthew Banks DDS link
10/10/2022 10:20:54 pm

Worry worry office lay order national even candidate. Wind over politics politics water safe field enough.
Stop old everybody traditional discuss why.

Reply
Michael Villarreal link
10/20/2022 11:50:32 pm

Information back head bank without because. Her college fear nothing.

Reply
Jonah Bond link
8/8/2023 10:03:33 am

Hi great reading yourr post

Reply
Move out Cleaning Tauranga link
8/11/2023 08:13:26 am

Enhance the lifespan of your furniture and fixtures with our specialized cleaning service. We use gentle yet effective techniques to preserve your investments.

Reply
Instagram follower service link
8/16/2023 12:37:18 pm

Display customer testimonials and case studies on your panel to build trust and demonstrate the effectiveness of your services.

Reply
Is VPS Airport Taxi Service Safe link
9/1/2023 02:44:55 am

Transitioning to a VPS has allowed us to maintain consistent website performance, even during traffic spikes.

Reply
therapy in Washington link
9/7/2023 03:47:09 am

Physical therapy for sports injuries helps athletes recover from injuries and improve performance through targeted exercises and treatments.

Reply
ทางเข้า gclub link
9/8/2023 02:48:16 am

The sound of slot machines ringing and the sight of coins pouring out are iconic moments in casino gambling.

Reply
เว็บไฮโลออนไลน์อันดับ 1 link
9/9/2023 02:37:07 am

The psychology of gambling is a fascinating field of study. It delves into the motivations, behaviors, and cognitive processes behind why people gamble and how they react to wins and losses.

Reply
online ib tutors link
9/9/2023 07:48:32 am

Tutors often serve as mentors, guiding students through life's challenges beyond academics.

Reply
wildjoker casino link
9/11/2023 03:46:14 am

Casinos have implemented countermeasures to discourage card counting, such as shuffling the decks more frequently or banning suspected card counters.

Reply
Ozwin Casino Australia link
9/14/2023 04:46:45 am

One of the things I love about gambling casinos is the sense of anticipation. Whether you're waiting for the roulette wheel to stop or the cards to be dealt, that moment of suspense is exhilarating.

Reply
Fair GO Australia link
9/16/2023 04:32:24 am

Gambling can be a way to test one's instincts and decision-making skills under pressure.

Reply
1 Win link
9/18/2023 04:21:40 am

The loyalty programs on some betting sites are worth taking advantage of. They reward your dedication.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Mr. Schaeffner is a certified instructor in the UTF (United Taekwondo Federation) and the GTA (Global Taekwondo Alliance). He is also the owner and head instructor of Rochester Family Martial Arts).

    Archives

    June 2018
    May 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly